Who got kicked off American Idol April 28 2010 : Top 5 Revealed. Magnus will most certainly find a career. But had she determined a more consistent path of song choices during the show she could have continued, as she has one of the strongest and most impressive voices of any remaining contestants.
In the end, her randomness was her undoing, as everyone else has carved out a specific niche already.

James has survived largely on his flowing locks and open shirt collars, as well as his guitar playing. His vocals are simply average, and if he is next to leave it wouldn't be a total shock, nor would it be a bad thing.